Question Words
Feels odd writing about my thoughts on the internet for everyone to read. Normally I keep my opinions/thoughts to myself unless asked. But seemed like you get a lot of good feedback/comments/advice from people who read blogs. My friend Joy Ghosh (joyghosh.blogspot) introduced me to this site.
Anyways, this first post is not about something deep or innovative or philosophical or any of that jazz, just a simple observation.
I was thinking, as usual, about ..., well, I was just thinking and realized how the question words all start with the same syllable/alphabet in all the languages I know. Seemed really odd initially when I went through the first couple of the six I know. Then... it just became more strange :). Maybe there is some real reason behind this, or maybe its just a co-incidence. Maybe I haven't used google enough to research and find out; hmm, that I guess could be because I just wanted to write my first blog on it :).
Okay, let me get to the point. In English, the following question words start with the same alphabet. (Btw, I just did a simple search on google and didn't find anything on this.)
"Who", "Why", "What", "Where", "When","Which". The only exception is "How". All the others start with a "w".
In Hindi (the national language of India), the same question words are:
Kaun, Kyon, Kya, Kahan, Kab, Kaunsa, Kaise.
In Tamil ( a south-Indian language), the same words are:
Evan, Endiku, Ennadu, Engay, Eppo, Edu, Epidi.
In Malayalam (another south-Indian language), they are:
Yaaru, Endinu, Endaa, Evada, Eppo, Edu, Engana.
In Marathi (another Indian language; no points for guessing where I am from), they are:
Koni, Kashaala, Kay, Kutha, Kadhi, Konta, Kasaa.
In French (yes, I know French), they are:
Qui, Pourquoi, Qui, Ou, Quand, Quel, Comment (seems like this language does not conform a lot and pardon me if I have made a mistake in listing the words - I stopped learning/reading French 7 years ago).
Was it done so that people could ask questions more easily to get around and to get things done even if they didn't know the language of the people they were "trapped" amongst? Yes, I know I have to come up with something more plausible :). Maybe it was because when language developed among the first humans, the most common words in their monosyllabl(istic?) language were these question words and they found it easy to say the same "sound" in different ways to convey different meanings (think of "who", "why", "wha(t)", "whe(re)", as examples of such monosyllables)?
Well, if you could list the above question words in your language (and/or any other languages you know), we could see if this holds true in general!
Ciao, its late in the night.
Anyways, this first post is not about something deep or innovative or philosophical or any of that jazz, just a simple observation.
I was thinking, as usual, about ..., well, I was just thinking and realized how the question words all start with the same syllable/alphabet in all the languages I know. Seemed really odd initially when I went through the first couple of the six I know. Then... it just became more strange :). Maybe there is some real reason behind this, or maybe its just a co-incidence. Maybe I haven't used google enough to research and find out; hmm, that I guess could be because I just wanted to write my first blog on it :).
Okay, let me get to the point. In English, the following question words start with the same alphabet. (Btw, I just did a simple search on google and didn't find anything on this.)
"Who", "Why", "What", "Where", "When","Which". The only exception is "How". All the others start with a "w".
In Hindi (the national language of India), the same question words are:
Kaun, Kyon, Kya, Kahan, Kab, Kaunsa, Kaise.
In Tamil ( a south-Indian language), the same words are:
Evan, Endiku, Ennadu, Engay, Eppo, Edu, Epidi.
In Malayalam (another south-Indian language), they are:
Yaaru, Endinu, Endaa, Evada, Eppo, Edu, Engana.
In Marathi (another Indian language; no points for guessing where I am from), they are:
Koni, Kashaala, Kay, Kutha, Kadhi, Konta, Kasaa.
In French (yes, I know French), they are:
Qui, Pourquoi, Qui, Ou, Quand, Quel, Comment (seems like this language does not conform a lot and pardon me if I have made a mistake in listing the words - I stopped learning/reading French 7 years ago).
Was it done so that people could ask questions more easily to get around and to get things done even if they didn't know the language of the people they were "trapped" amongst? Yes, I know I have to come up with something more plausible :). Maybe it was because when language developed among the first humans, the most common words in their monosyllabl(istic?) language were these question words and they found it easy to say the same "sound" in different ways to convey different meanings (think of "who", "why", "wha(t)", "whe(re)", as examples of such monosyllables)?
Well, if you could list the above question words in your language (and/or any other languages you know), we could see if this holds true in general!
Ciao, its late in the night.
posted by Anand Ganesh at 11:06 PM
7 Comments:
hey.. great start :) and an interesting observation.. as usual ;)
the english words in bengali are:
Ke, Keno, Ki, Kothay, Kokhon, Konta, Kikore.
I also like to believe that questions would come together more often as you realize a concept. So maybe they sounded alike with slight variations.
Do post more when u finish doing more research on it :D
3 out of 5 persons have used the same words 'interesting observation :) '.
some coincidence :)
A great observation indeed. I knew this fact about english, but never really pondered over the same in other languages too. However, like english... Gujrati also seems to have one exception:
'Kon', 'Kem', 'Shu', 'Kyan', 'Kyaare', 'Kayu', 'Kevi reete'
anan fanan...heres the listing from dutch..also a germanic language as english..guess u could philosophize on this...or not... have fun..or beer..!!!
cheers SP
"Who", "Why", "What", "Where", "When","Which". The only exception is "How". All the others start with a "w".
"wie", "waarom", "wat", "waar", "wanneer", "welke", "hoe"
I have been looking for sites like this for a long time. Thank you! foot fetish tampa Precor exercise equipment pilates for weight loss Delta dental plan of illinois Time & expense software vicodin cod no prescription cheap cod no phentermine rx pilates bench Saab sway bar Jack black take it back A1 appliance parts inc Sports authority md Capri cropped short pants Crest whitestrips uk consol humidifier pilates ball excercises examples automobile gps navigation san antonio web advertising
This comment has been removed by the author.
My contribution:
Same words in Spanish
Quien, por que, que, donde, cuando, cual, como.
Seems that spanish does not follow the logic, however the phonetics are very similar, Q and C sound in the same way.
I think that all these words have two things in common:
1) Besides they are monosyllable
they are also very easy and comfortable to say... Babies learn these words very early in their development. Which leads me to think that the similarity of these words in different languages is not a coincidence
2) From the beginning of the development of Human language People have used onomatopoeias to describe objects , sounds, and actions... so I wonder if these questions are some sort of onomatopoeias.
Post a Comment
<< Home